Showing posts with label Franklin Park. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Franklin Park. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 24, 2009

Thanksgiving At The Zoo

Boston Daily Globe November 30, 1923


Animals in Zoo Given Thanksgiving Dinner

Codliver oil and garlic may not sound like the average person’s idea of a real Thanksgiving dinner, but they were two of the most popular dishes at the Franklin Park Zoo yesterday. Deputy Park Commissioner William P. Long, following the custom of some years, ordered a Thanksgiving dinner for the birds and beasts at the Jamaica Plain institution, and last night every one was happy, even Mutt, the hyena.

The codliver oil was for the two Polar bears, Pasha and Fatima, and the big beasts lapped the dishes dry and begged for more. As for the garlic it is Tony’s, the youngest elephant’s idea of white meat and fixin’s. Curiously enough Waddy, the other elephant, will not touch garlic, but ate the regular dinner of hay, bread and carrots with relish.

The other inmates received the “eats” which they love best. There was fruit of various sorts for the monkeys, mutton for the brown, black and grizzly bears, and so on down the long list.

Thursday, July 17, 2008

Franklin Park Bear Dens


When men were men, and bears were out of luck. I left all these pictures full size to show detail. Click on the pictures to see the full versions.



Looking up at the approach to the bear dens.



From within the main bear cage, looking at the back right corner.




At the back of the main cage - bears stand guard over Boston - or are they attacking?



A bear's eye view, from inside the main cage.



Most of the doors at the back of the cage are sealed up. I had to crouch to shoot this picture inside the back wall of the cage.



The second cage, to the left of the main cage.


Not a happy place.


Inside the main cage - notice the round metal cage and barrel that protected a tree that grew within the cage.

Friday, March 7, 2008

Schoolmaster Hill - Franklin Park


If you refer back to the map in the previous entry, this structure is labeled "The Arbor." It sits on top of Schoolmaster hill overlooking the golf course at Franklin Park. As you approach it, it has the feel of a British archeological site.



This was taken just inside the doorway shown in the picture above. The columns obviously once supported a roof.



Continuing through the structure, the low walls extend in the direction of Blue Hill avenue, with little step-down "balconies" on the right that face out over the meadow/golf course.



This is looking back to the "Arbor" walk. Apparently, this was intended to support rose arbors, but they were removed early on in the history of the park.


The view overlooking the golf course. God I hate golf. You can see a bit of the Blue Hills, but only the lower Quincy side. Trees and a rising grade to the south-east hide the rest of the Blue Hill range from sight.


At the end of the stone structure, this plaque honoring Ralph Waldo Emerson sits on a Roxbury puddingstone boulder. Frederick Law Olmsted named this hill Schoolmaster after the time Emerson spend living in a cabin on the site.

Thursday, March 6, 2008

Mystery Solved... For What It's Worth

Richards, L.J. 1899 (copyright © 2000 by Cartography Associates)
David Rumsey Collection.

I'm reposting this map from my earlier entry on the lost Franklin Park reservoir. I said in that entry that I wanted to find out where the reservoir was, and today I took advantage of some nice weather to poke around Hagborne hill. Sure enough, I found a relatively level area with several manhole covers sitting strangely out of place in the woods. No doubt, that's the reservoir, marked by the "bourne" of "Hagbourne Hill" on the above map. There are picnic benches in various states of disrepair about the area, and a collection of metal trash barrels that are apparently kept there for the winter. If nothing else, the area seems to be a dog-walkers' paradise. Below is my manhole proof of location of the never-used reservoir of Franklin Park. Now I've satisfied my strange curiousity about the never-used, long-forgotten hole in the ground.


Does anyone wonder why there are manhole covers in the woods?


This is the only level land of this area in the "Wilderness" section of Franklin Park. There are a good 7-8 manhole covers within view of this picture. I assume the underground reservoir across much of the area.

Monday, February 4, 2008

Tobogganing At Franklin Park

Library of Congress


Click on the picture to get a larger version. The listing says it was taken in 1914. There is a mention in a Boston Globe article of a toboggan 'chute', so there may have been some kind of structure built at the top of the hill to add a little speed. It is probably the same place my parents went sledding in the 1930s. Winter sports in Boston just aren't what they used to be.

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

Ghosts At Franklin Park Zoo

I found the pictures below at the Library of Congress web site. They were taken in 1978, and apparently someone decided to record the buildings for posterity. It's a shame they didn't think to take pictures before they removed the animals - these photos are spooky to me. I remember the buildings, but only just. The last time my parents brought me to the zoo was probably 1965. In light of today's zoo practices, these buildings seem positively primitive. They were old and run down when I saw them, but the animals were no less grand for their surroundings. For those who wince at the tiny, bare quarters the animals were held in, a story. My father told me that when he was at the zoo once - probably pre-war - he watched an elderly woman approach the lion cage at the outside corner of the building. The cat, a big male, looked at the lady, lifted his leg, and sent a stream of piss directly towards her head. No doubt, the old lady took one for our sins, bless her soul.

I wonder what happened to the head that projected from the building above the front door of the elephant house. Did they just destroy it? It was modeled on one of the three original elephants who opened the zoo. There must be someone who knows the answer to this.












Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Franklin Park Zoo Grows and Grows



I vaguely remember visiting the zoo with my parents in the early Sixties. I do remember the elephant house, the big cat house, and the monkeys. For at least one summer, around 1967, St Thomas band held marching practice in the infield grounds just inside the Blue Hill avenue entrance. Unlike my mother, who had names for the zoo animals and pulled a sled from Amory or Oakdale street to the park to go sledding (think about it), I never spent much time at the zoo or park.

Go here to see a 1924 map of Franklin Park that shows the location of the lion and elephant houses, the bird cage and the bear pens.


On October 4, 1912, the new bear exhibit was opened at the Franklin Park zoo to an audience of nearly 10,000 people. Mayor Fitzgerald, City Council President Attridge and Councillor Ballentyne released 12 bears from their enclosed housing to the open pens near Walnut avenue. John T. Benson, curator of the zoo, boasted that the bear enclosure was the best in the world. Mayor Fitzgerald gave credit to George Parkman, whose bequest of $6,000,000 in 1910 for the parks of Boston destined the city to have the most wonderful parks in the world.

By June of the next year, two of 137 planned building had been built - the bear dens and the bird cage. Two monkeys were housed in a small circular building near the refectory, which stayed crowded throughout Sunday visiting hours. Present sensibilities would be deeply offended by the scene observed by the Globe reporter - a monkey given a hand mirror to play with, which it bit and broke, only to examine the resulting shards of glass. An agouti was in the next cage, and an adjutant stork, described as a "horrid bird." Its eye is "large, full of intelligence, and it has an expression of utter cynicism." Here, I think we can see the writer having some fun, as with the description of a camel on loan to the zoo - "He is an unpleasant, two-humped, supercilious affair..."

At the periphery of the temporary building were elk, a wild boar, and a buffalo. Bears, wolves, skunks and spotted ocelots were held there as well, with the building being planned for later use as a hospital and quarantine.

At the bird cage, which had been delayed in opening by a strike, four eagles perched on the branches of the enclosed trees, and a demoiselle crane performed its dance.

The bears included polar, Siberians, browns and a black, giving a population of 15, with Indian bears still to come.

The tropical birds in the collection had not all fared well, seven having died over the winter, including four flamingos from Florida and two German storks had died as well.


By December of the same year, permanent housing was in place near Blue Hill avenue for the buffalo, elk, llama, goat and red deer. Louis A. Mowbray, curator of the Aquarium, had taken temporary charge of the zoo since the retirement of John T. Benson, holding the position until the new curator, Arthur B. Baker, was to take over on the first of January.




In July of the following year, 2 lions and 10 monkeys arrived in Boston by steamship. The lions had been captured in Africa by Mr. Nelson Slater, who left Harvard and was "famous as a daring motorist, then turned to the African continent for thrills." Such were the times. Another donation to the zoo was a black bear cub from Oregon, given by the comedian Eddie Foy. The cub had been appearing with the Foy family at the Palace Theatre, and was said to be a favorite with women and children.



January of 1915 saw the opening of the new elephant house, home for Tony, Waddy and Mollie. The facility included an exercise yard and a pool 60 feet by 60 feet across, and sloping to seven feet deep. The elephants had come from a vaudeville show, and there was room to allow for similar performance.



A new round house contained leopards, pumas, wolves, red foxes and a wild-cat. The newly arrived lions were kept here, as well as one hyena. The polar bears enjoyed a swim in their pool, even when they needed to stamp through the ice to reach the water.


The second season of the Franklin Park Zoo started with a collection of 856 animals, including 705 birds and 151 mammals. Among the most popular attractions were the golden baboons, Jack and Jocko; Spider and Prince, the ring-tailed monkeys, Mutt, the spotted hyena and Sultan, the leopard.

In January of 1921, the lions, leopards and spotted hyena were moved to the new Lion House. Under the watchful eyes of the monkeys, and with meat tempting them into them each in succession into the travelling crate, each animal yielded and made the short trip. The exception was Sheila, the leopard, who refused the enticement offered and had to be corralled with a noose and drawn into the crate.










Resources: Boston Daily Globe, October 4, 1912, June 1, 1913, December 21, 1913, July 27, 1914, January 4, 1915, April 4, 1915, and January 14, 1921.

Sunday, January 20, 2008

Hagborne Hill Reservoir

Richards, L.J. 1899 (copyright © 2000 by Cartography Associates)
David Rumsey Collection.



In the center of the above map, you see Hagborne hill. If you're like me, as soon as the weather gets nice you'll want to talk a walk around the hill and look for evidence of the lost reservoir of Franklin Park. Even more, I'd love to know what's inside it now. I'd also like to know where the pumps of the Jamaica Pond Aqueduct Company were. And finally, I'd like to know the name of the Nimrod responsible for this disaster.


Boston Daily Globe October 26, 1902


Abandoned Hole. A Record Hall of Park Department. Reservoir Was Built in the Rock of Hagborne Hill. Meant to Supply Ponds of Franklin Park.


Boston has a great reservoir, built to hold water, which is utilized as a graveyard for public documents.

When it became apparent that the water shed of Franklin park was insufficient to keep the ponds full during the dry season and that it would be necessary to supplement the natural water supply, it was determined to utilize the plant of the Jamaica pond aqueduct corporation, laying an eight-inch pipe from the pumping station to a reservoir on Hagborne hill, and erecting standpipes along the line for road sprinkling purposes.

Work on the reservoir was begun in 1894. It was entirely below the original surface of the ground, and was excavated chiefly in rock, the bottom resting entirely on rock. This would have made the cost excessively high, except for the fact that material for road surfacing was obtained.

Inasmuch as the level of the water could not well be kept at a constant height and the appearance of the reservoir, if exposed, would be unsightly, it was thought best to have it covered.

The side walls were perpendicular, of American cement concrete, with a thickness nowhere less than one foot, the remaining space between the concrete and the ledge being filled with dry rubble.

Brick piers, 16 inches square, 10 inches high and 10 feet apart, were built for supporting the roof.

The top is covered today by 2 1/2 feet of loam.

The big main branches in a manhole just outside. The branch which was to supply the reservoir enters about six inches above the bottom, and is carried diagonally across nearly to the farther corner, where it ends in a globe-shaped casting, with an opening above. The branch which was to serve for an outflow pipe passes under the bottom and in embedded in concrete.

The reservoir covers an area of 9733 square feet, and has a capacity of 951,000 gallons, which is estimated to be a week's supply, n the driest time, for water carts on the drive between the reservoir and Jamaica park and also for making good the loss by evaporation from the ponds in Franklin park.

Difficulties arose which prevented the carrying out of the project, and the immense and costly reservoir, together with the tons of pipe, was abandoned. It was found that the water of Jamaica pond was too low to be carried to Hagborne hill without a more powerful pumping energy than could be supplied by the old Jamaica pond aqueduct pumps, and it was not deemed wise to construct a new pumping plant.

Since, the old pumping station has been removed, and instead of water in the great well in the park, the dry and musty records of the park department are to be found.Link


Update: I later walked around Hagborne hill and found evidence of the reservoir: Update

Saturday, January 19, 2008

Frankln Park Zoo - Animals Arriving


Boston Daily Globe May 5, 1912


Jungle Dwellers For The Zoo

Two Grizzly, Two Cinnamon and Two Black Bears Expected from the Yellowstone National Park for the Boston Collection of Wild Animals, Water Fowl and Beautifully Plumed Foreign Birds.

Large Flocks Of Game Birds Given by John E. Thayer.


Donations of animals and birds to the city of Boston for its new zoo at Franklin Park have been so frequent and so liberal up to date that it begins to look as if Curator John T. Benson of the zoo will have a good-sized collection of beasts to put in their proper places when the time rolls around for the official opening of the animals' and birds' new quarters.

Mr Benson has been much pleased with the immediate recognition which had been given the new institution by prominent collectors and naturalists all over the country. Not only friends of Boston alone, but many others interested in the spread of appreciation of the wonders of natural science have expressed a desire to do their part, no matter how small, and to aid in suggestions for the keeping of the mammals in not in personal donations.

"The fame of the new zoo and reports of our preparations for it," said Mr Benson in speaking of the interest that is being taken, "have already spread far and wide, so much so that I begin to think people in the other parts of the country have heard more about it than have Boston people. I have been receiving letters from prominent persons of different States, some of them in the West, all of whom have congratulated me, as the representative of the city, on the new departure, and have sought information. The immediate success of the enterprise is assured."

Meanwhile Curator Benson is doing what he can to hurry along the work of construction of the future homes of the animals and birds, viz, the bear dens, the flying cage and the service room for the reception of the live stock. No exact date for opening has been set. This will depend largely on the rapidity with which the work progresses from now on. Up to this time the laborers have been hampered often by difficulties imposed by the weather, yet the buildings have already taken definite shape.

While waiting for the completion of their Summer quarters the beasts are being temporarily housed in cages and pens built expressly for the purpose. Great care has been exercised in their keeping during the Winter months and every advantage has been offered them.

Perhaps the largest collection of any kind that has yet been presented to the Zoo and delivered to the keeper is that of water fowl, given by John E. Thayer of Lancaster, the well-known ornithologist and collector. The donation of this collection stands as another of the many public services which Mr Thayer has rendered along the line of natural science.

The group presented comprises a very large number of aquatic birds, many of them rare specimens, a collection the gathering of which undoubtedly required many years of patience. There are not only strange birds from other parts of the United States and Canada, but also several from foreign countries, such as Australia, Japan and China.

Specimens contained in the collection include pairs of comb geese, semipalmated geese, widgeon, tree ducks, shoveler ducks, ruddy sheldrakes, red heads, pintails, Egyptian geese and snow geese. Altogether a fine group of water fowl to start with.

With these are being kept six beautiful white swans which were given to the city by Howard Marston. These handsome birds occupy a prominent place in the whole collection.

A good start has also been made in the animal department. The first donation was that of a fine black bear, made by Newton Newkirk of Boston. The animal has been enjoying himself during the Winter in the recesses of a private dun which is kept in the Franklin Park yard. This present was followed by the gift of a young alligator and another of a Gila monster, a member of the lizard family. The givers of these withheld their names.

Still more recent has been the donation of a rare tortoise by Dr James B. Thornton of the Back Bay. This creature is known as a wood tortoise and its habitat is in the Southern climes, particularly in islands of the West Indies.

It came into the Dr Thornton's possession in a very peculiar way. One day when he was driving through Fenway in an automobile he saw the animal crossing the road at a rapid rate. He captured it and took it home, keeping it there during the Winter in a small cage which he made for it. The animal made a splendid pet, he states. It arose with the rest of the family in the morning, took its meals about the same time and usually went off to bed about 2 in the afternoon. In cold weather it crawled off into the darkness for days at a time.

An addition to the above collection of mammals is expected in a short time from the National Government, which has expressed its intention of taking some of the animals in Yellowstone National Park and transporting them to the Boston Zoo, there to have their habitation. This group will probably include four grizzly bears, two cinnamon bears and two blacks.

Curator Benson has received intimations that donations are to come from several other sources, and the fact has been well manifest that outsiders as well as the people of Boston are deeply interested in the success of the new zoo.

Franklin Park Zoo - Getting Closer.


Boston Daily Globe November 24, 1911


Pushing Work At Zoological Gardens. Iron and Masonry Parts Nearly Finished -- Bear Pits Practically complete and Great Bird Cage Progressing.


Work is being rapidly pushed at the Zoological Gardens at Franklin Park, the contractors endeavoring to have the iron and masonry work completed before the snow comes. At the bear pens the heavy walls are nearly finished and the pens themselves lack only a few minor additions.

The large bird cage that is being erected near Humbolt av is nearly completed as far as the iron work is concerned. During the past week the work of putting the girders in place has gone on.

The cage will be 210 feet long, 60 feet high and 50 feet wide, with a large arched roof. Inside the cage will be a number of trees for the birds to roost on and a large cement tank will be put in for the water fowl. I was the intention to have only water fowl in the cage, but it has been decided to put all kinds of birds there. At present the authorities have 37 different kinds of birds in the cage.

Owing to the cold the building of the tank will not start until early in the Spring.

Franklin Park Zoo - Opening Soon

I will note here that I'm pretty sure that the John Benson cited below was later the founder of Benson's Wild Animal Farm of Hudson New Hampshire. Or was it his son? Any one who grew up in the metro Boston area during the 1960s like I did will remember the name, and many will have visited the park. If I'm right about this, why did Mr Benson leave Franklin Park? Maybe someone will have an answer to leave in the Comments section.



Boston Daily Globe May 28, 1911


Boston Zoo Ready In A Year

J.T. Benson Has Been Nominated Curator.

Talks of His Experiences and of Franklin Park Plans.


By this time next year the new municipal zoo in Franklin park will be opened. It is expected at present, with the bear dens occupied and the denizens of the great flying cage on view to the public. Work has already started on the bear dens and Monday a large force of men will be employed on this one feature. If plans for the new Boston zoological gardens can be taken as any criterion for the completed zoo, Boston will undoubtedly have one of the finest such exhibits to be found in the world.

A Globe reporter visited the site of the proposed zoo in Franklin park last week to ascertain what had been done. There he found John T. Benson, who has been appointed curator of the zoo by park commissioners, subject to confirmation by Mayor Fitzgerald. His honor has not yet confirmed the selection of the park commissioners.

Mr Benson is well equipped for this great work, as he has been intimately associated with animals, birds and fish from his boyhood. Last winter he passed five months in the great European cities studying the zoos there and securing first-hand information as to the latest and best methods of housing and caring for park animals, birds, etc. During his trip he visited the great zoological gardens at Dublin, London, Paris, Berlin, Antwerp and Hamburg.

Being personally friendly with Hagenbeck, he visited that famous animal man's place at Hamburg, which is the most modern and best equipped in the world, he says. Because of his friendship he was permitted to make a careful study of the quarters, making measurements and plans of the cages, houses, drainage systems, etc, all of which would be invaluable to him here.

He says that owing to the rapid decrease in wild animals the world over, and the inability of people to study them in their native haunts, the demand for zoological gardens in being felt in all large cites, and those not yet having a zoo are preparing to establish one; their educational advantages are unlimited. He thinks Boston is particularly fortunate in having the great Parkman fund to help it with its work of establishing a zoo here.


[skip section about Mr Benson]


He took the Globe representative over the section of Franklin park to be devoted to the zoological garden, and showed him just where the men are engaged in grading and blasting for the bear dens, which is almost opposite Humbolt av, on the Seaver-st side of the park. It is an ideal location for the dens, which are to be made as natural as possible, consistent with proper drainage, etc.

Bids for the construction of the largest flying cage in the world are to be opened May 29 and it is expected that the cage will be completed and it feathered inhabitants in place by next May. This cage will be so large that it will entirely enclose six or eight great towering elms, now growing on the site, and the trees will be left undisturbed within the cage.

Dimensions of the Cage.

An idea of the size of this cage can be had from the fact that the cage in the Bronx park in New York is 132 feet long and 55 feet high, while that to be built at Franklin park will be 190 feet long and 56 feet high, or nearly 10 feet longer than the one in New York.

Plans have just been completed for the bear cages and dens, and the foundation work for these is already in progress. The cages will be completed and the animals installed in them by next year. There will be four of these great bear cages, with opportunity for more if desirable and accommodations will be provided for 23 or more bears. These cages will be built in Long Crough woods, near Seaver st.

The cages will be arranged in a great semicircle, before which is to be an open court, approached by a broad flight of steps. There is to be a fountain in the open court. About 10 feet from the front of the cages will be a barrier to prevent people getting too close to the animals, and between that and the cages will be a mass of low shrubbery. All four cages will have pools of about 20 feet width for the bears to swim in, and natural conditions will be simulated within the cages as much as possible. There will be trees within the cages, but they will be provided with guards to prevent the bears climbing and destroying them.

Each cage will be 90 feet in depth, not including the den portion, which will project from the rear. One cage is to be 130 feet long and the others about 90 feet long. Upon the suggestion of Mr Benson a drainage system will be installed so that the cages can be kept perfectly clean at all times.

Almost in front of the bear cages, under a great natural bowlder(sic) which is to act as a background for the cage, will be built the quarters of the lynx group. As little ironwork as possible will be used, but of necessity some must be visible, in the various cages. Next summer a great bird house is to be erected for winter quarters, and it will be ready to receive them by the time they most be taken in from the flying cage.

Mr Benson has already been in correspondence with a number of persons to secure animals and birds for the new zoo. In fact, at Franklin park there is a small black bear from Main, which has been donated to the new zoo by a Boston newspaper man. This bear was one year old last February. Other offers of bear, buffalo, elk and a wolf have already been made by a person wishing to donate them.

Mr Benson, in the work he has been doing at the park up to this time, has been given quarters in the office of supt Pettigrew, but he expects to change to the Overlook building and to share the rooms of the park police until some permanent offices are assigned the curator of the zoo.

The Zoo At Franklin Park

Note the dates of the articles. The wheels of government turn slowly. The Parkman Fund refers to money left by George Francis Parkman for the care of parks in the City of Boston.



Boston Daily Globe March 19, 1888


The "Zoo" at Franklin Park.


Definite arrangements have been concluded for the establishment of a zoological garden, in occupancy of that portion of Franklin Park on the corner of Walnut avenue and Seaver street, taking in the present entrance opposite School street, and extending along Seaver street about midway towards Blue Hill avenue, and covering a large tract of territory. This part of the grounds is particularly eligible for the purpose, on account of its rustic nature, a large part abounding in ledges, acclivities and groves. Suitable buildings will be erected in consonance with plans now being perfected, and the various components of a grand zoo, equalling at least anything in this country, will be furnished as speedily as possible.



June 25, 1910


Favors New Zoo At Franklin Park.

But Parkman Committee Takes No Action.

Recommends $10,000 be Used to Improve Charlesbank.


The special committee of the city council on the Parkman fund, Councilor Hale presiding, held a meeting at city hall yesterday afternoon at which the members discussed the project of establishing a zoo at Franklin park. There were representatives present from the art and park commissions.

The discussion was general, and though no definite action was taken, the members of the committee expressed themselves in favor of the establishment of the zoo.

The committee voted to report to the next meeting of the city council "ought to pass" on the order appropriating from the Parkman fund income for this year the sum of $10,000 to be used in improving the Charlesbank.

Friday, January 18, 2008

Curling On Scarboro Pond - 1903




Boston Daily Globe January 11, 1903


Play The Old Scotch Game.

Boston Curling Club Defeats the Country Club The Country Club's Representatives at Scarboro Pond, 46 to 36.


The Boston curling club and Country club of Brookline representatives met yesterday afternoon in a friendly match on the ice at Scarboro pond, Franklin park, the Boston curling club winning 46 to 36.

Three rinks were organized and the sport was enjoyed by all the participants. The ice was planed especially for the occasion, and although it was extremely keen, it had a bias which affected shots somewhat.

The first rink, skipped by Wrenton of the Boston curling club and Stevens of the Country club, had a tie score 13 to 13. The second rink went to the Boston curling club, Weinys'(sp?) four having a total of 21 to Jaques' 12. The third rink had a close contest, the Boston men winning by one point. The summary:

[scores followed]

The two curling clubs will meet in the national district medal series Saturday, Jan 24, at Scarboro pond, Franklin park.

Scarboro Pond at Franklin Park

Richards, L.J. 1899 (copyright © 2000 by Cartography Associates)
David Rumsey Collection.



Boston Daily Globe September 26, 1891


Ponds For Pleasure.

Three of Them Already Commenced in Franklin Park.


The work of constructing a chain of three artificial ponds has commenced at Franklin Park with the view of affording recreation, both winter and summer,for the children of Boston.

The ponds will be situated in the valley south of Scarboro hill, extending in a southwesterly direction, the third pond lying west of the circuit drive south of Rock Morton.

About six and a half acres will be covered by the ponds. Their depth will be eight feet in summer, but in winder the water will be drawn off so that the depth will be but four feet, and so prevent danger of drowning accidents, and allow skaters to pass under a rustic bridge situated between the second and third ponds.

Over the northerly shore of the largest pond a boathouse will be built where boats and canoes will be kept for hire. The ponds are so laid out as to add greatly to the beauty of the park.



January 30, 1902


Hockey Players Barred.

English High - Dorchester Game Postponed.

Schoolboys Indignant Over the Delay at Franklin Field.

Supt Pettigrew Will be Appealed to for a New Rink at Franklin Park.


The ice hockey game scheduled for yesterday afternoon at Franklin park between English high school and Dorchester high was postponed indefinitely, notwithstanding the fact that both teams were on the ice and ready to play.

Capt Hamburger of English high got his men ready to play at 3:30, but was notified by the officer on duty at Scarboro pond that he had received orders from Supt Pettigrew to prevent playing between the bridges, as it interfered with the other skaters.

The schoolboys were then allotted space above the westerly bridge, but when they went there, it was already taken possession of by the curlers from the Boston curling club, and as there was no possibility of playing without interfering with the curlers, the hockey players had to give up the idea of having a game.

The schoolboys now propose, if possible, to find out how things stand and they are indignant over the way they have been treated regarding Franklin field, and blame the park authorities for not insisting upon the contractor finishing his work so that the field may be flooded.

The also claim that the superintendent some weeks ago stated that a hockey rink would be provided for the boys at Franklin park, and that everything would be done to make up for the loss of Franklin field.

It is understood that a complaint has been made to the authorities that the hockey players monopolize the ice along with the curlers. Such is not the fact, as the rink, 180 by 80 feet, takes up comparatively small space and allows plenty of surface for the young people who are not interested in the game to enjoy themselves.

Hockey is exceptionally popular this year, and many teams practice at Franklin park whenever the ice is in good condition. Supt Pettigrew will be asked to provide a new rink by the school teams.

***********************************************************************************


Not all was beauty and fun when Scarboro pond was laid out and filled.


At about 3:30 on the afternoon of June 18, 1896, a canoe capsized on Scarboro pond. While W.T. Irving was pulled from the water by boatman in charge Herbert Stiles, P.M. Benway drowned in spite of the efforts of Patrolman George Riley.

On the evening of September 12, 1902, Mrs. Ellen A. Donovan was found drowned in Scarboro pond. Mrs. Donovan, a resident of Roxbury, had been an inmate at the Austin farm hospital just up Morton street, and had escaped from the institution in the morning.

On May 20, 1918, Miss Hansea Larson, 24, disappeared from the Boston State hospital, and committed suicide by drowning herself at Scarboro pond.

Sadly, whether through accident or intent, on rare occasions Scarboro pond became a scene of tragedy.


Note: I followed the spelling of the article, but you may see Scarborough as well.

Thursday, January 17, 2008

Franklin Park - Against and For

These two articles give some of the back and forth over the development of Franklin Park. You can see what the area looked like both before and after the park was founded in the these linked maps from 1874 and 1884 from the Jamaica Plain Historical Society web site.


Boston Daily Globe March 24, 1886


Franklin Park Betterments.

Public Hearing in the Council Chamber Yesterday.


The committee on claims gave a public hearing yesterday in the Council chamber on the subject of betterments assessed on account of laying out West Roxbury, now Franklin Park. There was a large attendance of interested persons. Nearly every seat in the chamber was occupied, the seats of Councilmen Lee, Dugan and Foss being filled by three ladies.

Alderman Hart, chairman, called the committee to order at 2:16 p.m. There were present Aldremen Hart, Sullivan and Freeman, and Councilmen Blume, Regan and Brown of the committee, and Corporation Counsel Nettleton. Thomas P. Proctor appeared for the Milton heirs of the petitioners.

After the reading of the petition, Richard Olney stated that he appeared on behalf of William Minot and others. He made an opening statement to the effect that he appeared, not as a particular representative of any one or several persons, but for all the persons assessed. He thought it would be a scandal to let the big fish escape and the little ones suffer. Most of the cases were in court. He thought some action should be taken to do away with the assessment. Unless it was so done, the city would be unable to collect more than a small portion of the betterments.

M.D. Ross called attention to Mr Olmsted's report and exhibited surveyor's plans to show that a new park road, designed to go through the place, destroyed six building lots and wiped out one house altogether. He did not complain of this, but he wanted to show how hard it was for him to sell his property under the existing uncertainty.

L. Foster Morse, a real estate broker, testified that the taking of the park for a public playground injured every estate bordering on it. With all due respect to Mr Dalton, he thought there was not a park betterment assessed that could be collected.

William Minot Jr., said the whole question of betterments was an experiment. The rise in value of Back Bay land was largely due not only to the park but to the improvements in health and sewers. The city had made a jump in the dark and trusted to time to show a betterment.

William P. Carter, a farmer, testified to the nuisance caused by stealing by visitors to the park. He owned six acres on which the betterment was $300. He would not sell his land less than $2000 an acre, because it cost him that much. The land in the neighborhood could not increase much, as the city had established a pauper institution and a small-pox hospital within three minutes walk. Milton A. Kent and A.T. Calder testified to the same effect as Mr. Carter and other witnesses.

Mr Olney stated that Mr. Bowditch had sold property for $19,000 since the park was laid out, for which he refused $23,000 some years ago. Mr Olney then read a communication from Hon. Marshall P. Wilder, who said the estates were not bettered by the park. He claimed that as his property was devoted to experimental agriculture in the testing of fruits for the benefit of the whole country, and would never be sold for house lots, it ought not be taxed. The petitioners put in the following figures collected by real estate men in regard to fifteen estates charged with betterments. There were 118 acres in all. The park assessment was $30,321; the betterment was $30,642. Between 1883 and 1885 the assessors books show that seven of these estates were not increased at all. The remaining were increased and two decreased. The total increase is $20,100. The park commissioners' estimated increase is $61,842; of these six estates one was $11,700 more than half the total increase.

A letter was read from Samuel Bradstreet and the hearing was adjourned to Friday, March 2d, at 1:30 p.m.



May 30, 1886


The Park Is For The People.


Franklin Park, is the sun shines today, will be visited no doubt by thousands of people from the crowded districts of Boston Proper. Monday and Tuesday, the columns of those of our contemporaries who make it their mission to air the grievances of well-to-do grumblers will bristle with letters complaining of their "vandalism." We shall be told about "the mob," and how it damaged the park, tearing the trees to pieces, despoiling them of their blossoms and playing havoc generally. All of which will be untrue, so far as it represents the frequenters of Franklin Park as in any sense a rough or disorderly body of people, while as to the flower-picking accusation it is simply trumpery impertinence. The West Roxbury lands have been bought by the people of Boston for the people of Boston's use and pleasure. As yet they are not laid out, nor cultivated, nor policed. They are in a wild state of picturesque natural beauty. The people have a right to flock there on Sunday, and to every well-ordered mind it is a positive pleasure to see the happy throngs of hard-working men and women strolling over the green fields, with groups of delighted children, from the city streets where grass and the blossoms of the orchards, are never seen. They have not, so far, been guilty of any disorderly conduct, though it is no doubt true that they have gathered bunches of lilacs, a few boughs of hawthorne, a handful of apple blossoms, or made up boquets of wild flowers, daisies, buttercups and clovers to carry back as souvenirs of their outing and light up their humble homes in the heart of the city with a little color from the country. Why not? Where is the kindly-disposed person who grudges them this little gratification? One of Boston's ex-mayors, commenting on the recent ridiculous complaints on this score, says: I rejoice that the Franklin Park lands are not yet laid out in apple-pie order, and it does my heart good to see the thousands of city people roaming at will over them every Sunday, and enjoying the full liberty of them. The blossoms will soon fade and fall away, and if they are picked to carry back to the city homes where flowers are so rarely seen, I don't see why there need be any fuss made about it." The truth is Franklin Park is serving its purpose as a public breathing space and pleasure ground for the people very admirably. But some folks will never feel happy about it until it is all fenced in, gravel-walked, flower-bedded and lawn-mowered, with an iron sign-post put up every few rods -- "Keep off the grass" -- and a policeman at every corner to see that nothing is touched.

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

Design Plan For Franklin Park



This sketch comes from the Boston Daily Globe, February 18, 1886. The West Roxbury park is now Franklin Park. Benjamin Franklin had left the city of Boston a sum of money, to be invested and kept for 100 years. The city considered uses for the money - approximately $200,000 in 1882 - and voted in that year to use the money to retire the debt resulting from buying the land for the West Roxbury Park, and to name the park in honor of its illustrious benefactor. The actual renaming doesn't show up in the Globe archive until we see it on the sketch above.

Note that although the layout of the park shown above is very much like we know it now, there was no zoo and no golf course.

Addendum: Commenter Meg reminds me that the money from the Franklin fund was not used for Franklin Park. Due to a lawsuit by the heirs of Benjamin Franklin, that source of money was tied up in the courts, and the city paid for the park from other sources.


Additional source: Boston Daily Globe January 24, 1882

A Day At The Park

These observations by a Boston Globe reporter came after the park land had been purchased, but before it had been laid out by Frederick Law Olmsted. There had been complaints about the crowds by abutters, so this may have been pro-park propaganda by the civic boosters at the Globe.



Boston Daily Globe June 29, 1885


Flocking To The Fields.

West Roxbury Park Visited by 20,000 People.

They Were Still Coming When the Rain Put an End to the Fun.

What a Five Minute's Shower Will Cost the Tourists.


The tide of travel was decidedly southward yesterday. West Roxbury Park has been a city Pleasure ground for a few seasons only, and the Common has many attractions to old residents, who go there from force of habit. From present indications its day is over, and hereafter those who want a few hours out will go elsewhither. Young people, fellows with their girls, and ladies and gentlemen, who with a sea breeze and clam chowder go to City Point this year, and young married people with their children, as well as citizens of a mature age, who simply want a ride and a view of country scenery, will go to West Roxbury.

To meet the demand that was evidently coming the Highland railway ran its usual cars to the depots, to Cornhill and to Temple place, and put on two additional lines, one ending at Park square and the other at Dover street. By this arrangement some arrived at and left Oakland Garden every minute from 10 o'clock a.m. until after the rain. They were needed, too. By 1 o'clock every bit of seating room was filled before reaching Dudley street, and in several instances the steps and platforms were loaded.

Groups of early risers, workingmen and boys,

Began to Stroll Into the Park

hours before noon. As the sun rose higher ladies and children added their bright garments to the browns and blacks of the gentlemen, making the green fields gay with variegated tints of red and blue, old gold and many metallic hues. Summer suits with straw hats and yellow shoes, were all the rage. Fully one-fourth of all the 20,000 people who were on the ground at 3 o'clock were children, ranging from 2 to 14 years of age. These were in the main tastefully dressed in light clothes, while many of them were ornamented with gay sashes. If they were representative Boston children the coming generation will not lack for beauty.

As the object of the excursions was evidently a ride and a view of the woods and fields the older members of the company sauntered from field to field, taking in the scenes, while the little folks ran and scampered like lambs. At the different ponds the usual game of making a big, good-natured dog go into the water after a stick was played by the boys, who enjoyed seeing the dog swim, and did not object to having him shake himself on coming out, even if they got wet by the performance. One dog, and great black Newfoundland, was kept busy all the afternoon, and swam many miles. Bouquets of ox-eye daisies, buttercups, fern leaves, clover and other plants were in great demand, as indeed were leaves, moss and fragments of stone. Every person

Had One or More Keepsakes

as a reminder of the day. The soda fountain and the ice-cream stand were patronized fairly well, but a majority were in pursuit of more aesthetic delights.

Shortly after 2 o'clock the clouds, which had been in the sky all day, began to grow denser, and soon it was evident that a heavy rain was close at hand. A few hundred of the more wise pleasure-seekers took the hint and hurried towards the cars. The majority however, felt that they were out for the day and were not to be frightened by a threatened shower. The clouds continued to grow darker and darker, and a few minutes after 4 o'clock the rain came down. Those in the woods far away from all shelter were the first to receive it. Then there was a rush. Silk dresses were taken up around the waists of the ladies, who held them there as they scampered across the fields and recklessly scaled stone fences that would on other occasions have been impassable barriers. Pocket handkerchiefs, shawls and lunch baskets were indiscriminately used as shields. Not one in a hundred had an umbrella. The few fortunate possessors of those useful articles were besieged by dozens of friends, who huddled around them in dripping masses. Many of the ladies had such pretty parasols, but they were of such small size that they were almost useless. Some of the ladies had such pretty parasols that rather than let the rain spoil them they preferred a ducking for themselves.

Every available place of shelter was crowded to suffocation. The car station restaurants and ice-cream tents were so crowded that it was with difficulty the waiters could move about. It was very warm in those places, and the demand for ices and cooling drinks was something tremendous. At one of the hotels, twelve quarts of ice-cream were disposed of during the few minutes that the shower lasted. It is impossible to estimate the number of quarts of

Soda Water, Ginger Beer and Tonic

absorbed during that time. When it began to rain there were about twenty-five open cars waiting on the tracks in front of the park. These were filled in a very short time. There were several box cars, which were soon packed The rain continued for about ten minutes, and the clouds then broke apart, giving promise of a pleasant evening. Soon the fields were again covered with the happy promenaders. The rocks were now carefully selected for seats, instead of the grass.

Though the rain was of short duration, great damage was done. A reporter sitting on the piazza of the car station overheard fragments of a conversation between two young ladies. "Oh," said one, "I do wish I was at home. I'm wet all over. Won't we get a lovely cold. My feet are soaked. Oh, Julia, do you know I believe that the color in those pretty stockings of mine has run I declare, it's a shame. They were such a lovely shade, and I only bought them yesterday."

"Botheration," replied the other young lady. "If I didn't have anything more than that to worry about, I'd by happy. Just look at that new feather in my hat - all wilted out like a drowned hen; and those pretty flowers, - why they don't look any more like roses than you do."

Tuesday, January 15, 2008

Artillery Bivouac at West Roxbury Park

This is a neat story - an artillery unit camped out for the night at the future Franklin Park on their way from Newport, Rhode Island to South Framingham.



Boston Daily Globe June 5, 1885


Battery B's Bivouac.

Artillerymen Spend the Night at West Roxbury Park.


The bivouac fires of Battery B, Fourth Regiment, United States Artillery, merrily burned at West Roxbury Park last evening, and a large number of visitors viewed the camp and were courteously received by Brevet-Major John Eagen, the officer in Command. The battery, which is on its way to South Framingham, where it will remain next wee,, left its headquarters at Fort Adams, Newport, on Monday last, and has come over the roads by easy marches, averaging three miles per hour. Monday night the command pitched camp a mile or two outside Fall River. Tuesday night was spent on the fair grounds at Taunton, and Randolph was the scene of Wednesday night's encampment. The battery reached the West Roxbury Park about noon yesterday and was received by Generals Dalton and wales of Governor Robinson's staff. The camp is on the outskirts of a small grove, near which runs a small stream of clear sparkling water. The officer's tents are located on a slight knoll, while below on a gentle incline and in view of a stone wall beyond are the guns. These are four in number, and of an entirely modern pattern being 3-inch rifled cannon. The battery has sixty horses, and these are secured at a point a short distance within the grove. The battery is thoroughly equipped and includes forge, kitchen and ambulance wagons. A captain, two first lieutenants, one second lieutenant and sixty-five men constitute the force manning the battery, and in each limber are 225 rounds of ammunition. The greater part of this comprises blank cartridges for use during the coming week, but there are also a few shells for target practice. The battery is officered as follows: Captain, John Egan (brevet-major): first lieutenant, R.R. Strong; first lieutenant, L.N. Walker; second lieutenant, H.E. Schroeder.

Battery B is stated to be one of the best in the regiment. Lieutenant Walker was officer of the day yesterday and the guard consisted of Sergeant Parker, Corporal Knipple and Privates Garrity, wood, Noble, Schwiveller, Broderick and Bresnahan. Among the visitors last night were Colonel w.M. Strachan and other militia officers. "Taps" were sounded at 9 o'clock, and soon silence reigned throughout the camp, broken now and then by voices of the guard or the neighing of a horse. The battery will break camp about 8 o'clock this morning, and after "boots and saddles" the command will leave the park and march through Walnut avenue, Warren street, Washington street, Chester Park, Columbus avenue, Boylston, Tremont and Beacon streets to the Common, where a salute will be fired in the Governor's honor. This event will probably take place about 11 o'clock. The battery will then reform and march to the State camp ground at South Framingham.

Victims of West Roxbury Park

Not everyone was happy with the new park - particularly those who felt an undue burden in paying for it. In this case abuttors were to be levied an extra tax assessment for having their vicinity "improved" by the park. There were similar protests when abuttors were asked to pay for the improvements to that waterway.


Boston Daily Globe April 21, 1885


West Roxbury Victims.

Neighbors of the Park Meet to Protest Against the Betterment Scheme.

About 150 persons assembled in Wetherell Hall, Grove Hall, last evening, in answer to the call for the "victims of West Roxbury park." The meeting organized by the choice of J.M. Way as chairman, and I.W. Adams as secretary. Mr Way said that he felt strongly the outrage of levying taxes on the surrounding property for the fitting up of West Roxbury park. He thought that the property was taxed enough now, and hoped the meeting would pronounce a strong opposition to it.

Mr Albert Betteley presented the following petition:

The Honorable Mayor and Aldermen of the City of Boston, and Benjamin Dean, Patrick Maguire and C.H. Dolan, Park Commissioners:

Gentlemen - The undersigned citizens of Boston, owners of real estate and residents of Roxbury and West Roxbury, and who have received notice through the newspapers that it is proposed to assess them for betterments to their estate by the establishment of the so-called West Roxbury park, hereby protest against such assessment on the ground that said park will not be a benefit to their property or to them. For if there was no park, many persons would purchase parts of this property and would erect houses for themselves as well as for others upon it, which would bring a large income to the city as taxable property and lessen the burden of taxation which is now drawing out of this city many of its citizens. That the visitors to this park, especially on Sundays and holidays, are not the most desirable persons, and that on the days mentioned the cars are so crowded that the residents in the vicinity cannnot without serious inconvenience reach their homes, and that hordes of rude persons are now a great annoyance to quiet and orderly inhabitants living in the neighborhood of this park, and that this trouble will continually be on the increase. That we believe that today, as well as in the future, the park will be a great damage to their property, and in fact the city is bound to pay us damages instead of our paying to the city for so-called betterments.

Signed by S.A. Bolster (judge of Roxbury Municipal Court). Martin L. Cate, A.D. Williams, L.J. Wood, E.C.R. Walther, Leonard Ware, Jr., and others.

Boston, April 20, 1885.


Mr. Betteley explained how he had been driven from different parts of the city on account of various annoyances. At the North End it was the pawnbrokers, at the South End there was other troubles and now at West Roxbury it was the betterment scheme.

George O. Fillebrown said he didn't propose to pay one cent for betterments, for he did not think the assessment morally or legally right. He said it was impossible to get as much for property as they could before the park was thought of. He was willing to subscribe $10 to fight the scheme "to the bitter end, but not one cent for tribute." In conclusion he moved that a committee of five be appointed to conduct the case of the remonstrances before the park commissioners and as much further as necessary.

While the chairman was making up this committee General Hazard Stevens was invited to speak. General Stevens thought that this betterment scheme was in the nature of a fishing excursion on the part of the commissioners. "The park commissioners want," said he, "to reduce the cost of the park by taxing us. It is our duty to oppose them and go to them and show them their mistake. That park does not benefit us as much as it does those who live in the crowded parts of the city. We are willing to pay our part in taxes, but it is not right for us to pay for a special benefit."

The chairman announced this committee: General Hazard Stevens, Samuel Atherton, Albert Betteley, William Minot, Jr., and Augustus Parker. The chairman was added to the committee. The question of finances was then discussed. Mr. Betteley moved that the meeting subscribe a sum not more than $5 nor less than $2 to carry on work. An amendment that "each member subscribe according to his means" was carried. The chairman was appointed treasurer, and a very satisfactory contribution was obtained. At the close of the meeting the petition was numerously signed.

Monday, January 14, 2008

Olmsted Speaks

Frederick Law Olmsted saw the proposed West Roxbury (Franklin) park as a place for passive enjoyment. No ball fields, no games and no gardens were planned. It was a time when reformers wanted to get urban workers out of the city and in to an uplifting "natural" environment. Soon after the park was opened, the people decided otherwise, but this article gives us some insight into the thinking of the man himself.



Boston Daily Globe October 29, 1884


Landscape Architecture.

Plans and Theories of Laying Out Public Parks - Sylvan Features to Be Adhered to in the City Lands at West Roxbury.


The park commissioners recently requested F.L. Olmsted, landscape architect, to prepare plans for the laying out of West Roxbury Park. When asked in regard to the matter yesterday, Mr. Olmsted replied:

"I have avoided giving any special study to the laying out of this park until I could obtain accurate information by the survey of the topographer, lest the impressions which I should get by a mere cursory examination might in some way lead me into wrong ideas, and give me a false start in some respect. Therefore all I can say with respect to the plan for laying out the park would be what would be applicable to any large park. There is no purpose commonly expected to be met in a park - or in the grounds called parks - that requires a very large area, except that of the simpler forms of rural recreation, and the value of the West Roxbury park will depend wholly upon the degree in which it will present natural scenes of beauty. The first thing to be thought of will be the drainage. The park will have to be put in the best possible sanitary condition. The next thing to be considered will be the number of entrances to be made, and where to locate them so as best to suit the convenience of the public. Then the roads and walks must be laid out in such a manner as to present the sylvan and rural features of the park to the best advantage.

"There are not many houses left in the park," said Mr. Olmsted. "I think that nearly all of them will necessarily have to come down. There should be no artificial structures in the park that are no to necessary for comfort. One or two houses will no doubt be retained for administration purposes. One is now occupied by the engineer, and we are intending to fit up another as an office of the landscape gardener. The matter has not received any attention yet but if it should be found that one or two of the houses are well adapted to the purpose of shelter and refreshment houses they will no doubt be used for those purposes.

"As large a part of the park as possible will be kept under greensward. There has been no thought of growing plants; that is to say, the Public Garden, for example, is what may be called a decorated ground; it is not intended that the West Roxbury Park shall be a decorated ground at all. It is intended that it shall have a simple, natural character. The propagating house and nursery to be located there are for propagating material that it is difficult to obtain in the commercial nurseries in sufficient quantities, and are chiefly for low-growing plants, to be used in covering surfaces that are not adapted to grass."

Mr. Olmsted dwelt particularly upon the fact that Boston is largely made up of what were formerly a number of distinct local communities.

"Each of these is," he said, "habituated to regard its public affairs from an independent point of view, and sometimes in spirit of competition and jealousy toward the others."

To this, he added, he had called attention of the park commissioners in a communication. The site of the West Roxbury Park offered special qualities that could not "be gained in a tenth part of that measure at ten times the cost" on some other sites for parks that might be named. That park should be looked upon as one of the parks of the city of Boston, and not especially for the residents of the city in which it is located. The distinctive qualities of the park might, he said, be summarized as follows, to quote from the communication referred to: Complete escape from the town; open country; pastoral scenery; a lovely dale, gently winding between low wooded slopes, giving a broad expanse of unbroken turf, lost in the distance under scattered trees."

The plans for the laying out will be prepared during the winter. Mr Olmsetd expects that the work itself will be commenced in earnest in the spring.